Connect with us
Saturday Night Fever review
Image: Paramount Pictures

Film

Saturday Night Fever is a Lot Darker Than You Remember 

Saturday Night Fever at 45!

How does the popular imagination remember 1977’s Saturday Night Fever, which arrived 45 years ago this week? Much of that cultural headspace entails John Travolta, strutting down a street in Brooklyn, as the Bee Gees’ “Staying Alive” plays. Much of the rest of it has Travolta dancing like a God to disco music on the sort of light-up dance floor that only existed in the late ’70s. 

All of that is real, and all of it is spectacular. The film offers one of the best soundtracks in the history of movies, featuring the Bee Gees and many other major disco music acts, and Travolta is magnetic in the role, absolutely believable as a man whose dancing is able to turn every head in the room. 

 But at the same time, Saturday Night Fever is dark as hell, full of sad and horrific things, all dealt with with a tone of moral ambiguity. Directed by John Badham, who replaced John G. Avildsen shortly before production began, it’s very much a movie of the ’70s, in other words. 

And make no mistake: things get very, very dark. There are multiple rape scenes, including an attempted one perpetrated by the movie’s hero, as well as a suicide, lots of violence, a plethora of racial slurs, and many, many scenes of Brooklyn Italians yelling at each other. 

Saturday Night Fever
Image: Paramount Pictures

There’s also the part about how disco was a genre and lifestyle created by gay and Black people, yet the hit movie about it that followed a couple of years later was almost entirely about straight white people, and that the film was adapted from a magazine article that turned out to be almost entirely fabricated, by a British writer who came to New York to write about the disco scene but barely left his hotel. 

Travolta, in his breakthrough movie performance at age 23, plays 19-year-old Tony Manero, an Italian-American native of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, who lives for his nights on the dance floor at the 2001 Odyssey, usually followed by getting drunk and climbing up the pulleys of the Verrazano Narrows Bridge. But the rest of the time, his life sucks. 

He lives with his squawking mother and father, as well as a brother who recently quit the priesthood, and he works a dead-end job at a paint shop. He hangs out most of the time with a group of guys who he doesn’t respect much, and he can’t seem to straighten out his romantic life either. 

Tony also seems to be lacking in ambition. He’s obviously talented enough to become some type of professional dancer but doesn’t seem to have the drive or the knowledge to get there. 

Saturday Night Fever
Image: Paramount Pictures

Less defensible is that the film treats the subject of rape with a lack of gravity that would be absolutely horrific by today’s standards. Tony, the film’s hero, attempts to rape his dance contest partner Stephanie, and she fights him off; later that night, Tony is present in the car when another woman, his former dance partner, is raped by one of his friends, and he does nothing to stop it. 

Then, in the film’s final scene — the next morning! — Tony goes to Stephanie’s house, apologies, she forgives him, and that’s that. 

Saturday Night Fever‘s story is told quite well, in a way that — bogus source material notwithstanding — is likely an accurate description of the language and behavior of blue-collar Italian-American men in 1970s Bay Ridge. The all-time favorite film of the late critic Gene Siskel, it’s a movie deserving of its place in the cultural canon. 

Written By

Stephen Silver is a journalist and film critic based in the Philadelphia area. He is the co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle and a Rotten Tomatoes-listed critic since 2008, and his work has appeared in New York Press, Philly Voice, The Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tablet, The Times of Israel, and RogerEbert.com. In 2009, he became the first American journalist to interview both a sitting FCC chairman and a sitting host of "Jeopardy" on the same day.

5 Comments

5 Comments

  1. Rosie Lowe

    December 17, 2022 at 10:44 am

    This is one of the trashiest movies ever made. Travolta’s character is disgusting. His buddies are disgusting. They curse, rape and they are supposed to be so cool. A bunch of jerks. And Stephanie! A total idiot.

  2. Andrew Kidd

    December 19, 2022 at 12:04 am

    Kyle Smith also wrote an excellent piece in National Review a few years back expanding on these very facts. It’s a very good film but also a very sad and tragic film, one that makes a better companion to Mean Streets than to Grease or American Graffiti. Also, like Mean Streets, it seems to inspired in part by Federico Fellini’s I Vitelloni.

  3. Dom Thomas

    March 16, 2023 at 7:26 pm

    I feel like the last paragraph really undermines the rest of this article. You’ve pointed out all of the flaws of the film perfectly throughout, but somehow concluded – without really mentioning why – the movie still deserves a place in the cultural canon? It seems like a bit of U-turn. I’d just like to know a bit more about why you think it still holds up as a classic, despite the horrendously inconsequential rape scenes and the way that it ends.

  4. mark

    May 7, 2023 at 1:38 am

    Funny. I knew a lot of jewish guys who acted just like that in the 1970s in brooklyn. An awful lot. Surprised you missed them in your short, vulgar assessment of Italian Americans from Brooklyn.
    See, in my family…my brother is a lawyer, my sisters a doctor, teacher and accountant.
    What’s it like having ethnic disdain for a group?
    With your last name, you should be more sensitive.

  5. Manhattan Bridges

    January 19, 2024 at 11:07 pm

    Like many other movies of that era, this movie would not pass in these times.
    Grease is another example of misogyny, poor treatment of women and a blasé attitude towards sex, rape, abortion and fighting. It’s still one of the highest selling movies in history.
    Brooklyn in the 1970s was nothing like it is today.
    For young men with no ambition from low social economic backgrounds this was typical in SOME areas. They were just bored and doing stupid things.
    This movie is not a ‘how to’ piece, it is fiction and representative of that time period.

    Enjoy the soundtrack. Watch the movie for what it is and enjoy the fact that we have moved on as a culture from what things used to be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

Protected: Robert De Niro’s 7 Children: Everything to Know

Celebrity

Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande constitute the global viewers’ attention “All About the Wicked” movie cast.

Celebrity

Latto Pulled Up To Angel Reese’s WNBA Debut In Style

Celebrity

Pharrell Williams tells us about his biopic in LEGO, ‘Piece By Piece’: “This is an amazing experience of history for me”

Celebrity

Who Is Christopher Lloyd’s Wife? For How Long Has He Married Lisa?

Celebrity

Thomas Rhett and Lauren Akins’ Relationship Timeline: How Did They First Meet?

Celebrity

Amanda Renner Divorce: Unveiling the Truth Behind Her Divorce Rumors!

Celebrity

Who is Chris Pratt’s Wife? Chris Pratt and Katherine Schwarzenegger’s Dating History!

Celebrity

Who Is Kevin Costner’s Ex-Wife? Has He Finalized His Divorce with Christine Baumgartner?

Celebrity

Who Is Adele’s Boyfriend? Explore the Renowned American Singer’s Love Life!

Celebrity

Busta Rhymes Returns To Acting With Role In “Naked Gun” Reboot

Celebrity

Who Is The Undertaker’s Wife? Get to Know the Wife of a Legendary American Wrestler! 

Celebrity

David Copperfield Sexual Accusation Unveiled: Women in Alleged Sexual Abuse Narrate Ordeal!

Celebrity

Antonio Brown’s net worth: Is he really worth -$3 million?

Culture

Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck Relationship Turmoil! What’s Causing Their Trouble?

Celebrity

Who Is Jordana Brewster’s Husband? Relationship Timeline Explored!

Celebrity

Connect