Connect with us
Never Let Me Go 2010

Film

10 Years Later: Never Let Me Go is a Noble Misfire

Welcome to Hailsham. The students have everything they need, except time.

When music video directors make the move to feature-film directing, accusations of “style before substance” arise almost as a critical reflex, even in cases where it’s not entirely merited. In Mark Romanek’s One Hour Photo, the director’s elaborate visual style and chilly sense of distance from the material might have seemed needlessly affected to some, but it actually bolstered the film’s feeling of isolation, and its winning central performance from an unusually sharp Robin Williams. The same harmonious match of tone and material doesn’t apply to his long-awaited second feature Never Let Me Go, derived from Kazuo Ishiguro’s acclaimed novel of the same name.

Adapted for the screen by frequent Danny Boyle collaborator Alex Garland, the film opens (after a brief scene considerably later) in 1978 at a seemingly average private school somewhere in Britain, wherein the children are kept under strict supervision (especially from headmaster Charlotte Rampling). Gradually, signs of abnormality crop up, from the electronic monitoring devices on every child’s arm to the outlandish rumors of doom for anyone who strays off school property. Of the students, we exclusively follow three: shy, caring Kathy (Izzy Mikle-Small; later, and principally, Carey Mulligan); mercurial and frail Tommy (Charlie Rowe; Andrew Garfield) and conniving, needy Ruth (Ella Purnell; Keira Knightley). As a tentative love triangle forms, with the eternally crestfallen Kathy seemingly destined to lose out against the more assertive Ruth for Tommy’s attention, the truth about the nature of the institution is brusquely revealed when a sensitive new “Guardian” (Sally Hawkins, naturally) decides she can no longer accept the students’ carefully managed ignorance abut their existence.

Never Let Me Go 2010

This information – kept secret in the film’s trailers – should imbue the film and its characters with disparate, extreme emotional energy, but curiously, Never Let Me Go only has one setting: sad contemplation. Thanks in large part to Mulligan’s incredibly sympathetic presence (as well as a very well-cast Knightley, exploiting her subtly aggressive features), Romanek certainly has no difficulty exploiting the scenario’s many, many crushing beats, but before long the one-note treatment grows tiresome. Bound together in muted shades of gray and green, and frequently given to wide exterior shots, Romanek’s visuals complement the gloom, but Rachel Portman’s score too strongly underlines the emotional intensity of scenes whose content provide more than enough tearjerking fodder. Though much of the film’s mournful final act is well-executed, in large thanks to the uniformly strong cast, Mulligan’s closing narration – much as it was in An Education – is shockingly pat, putting far too fine a point on a narrative that until that point had largely stayed away from clumsy sermonizing.

Never Let Me Go 2010

Never Let Me Go ultimately feels like a noble misfire.

The aforementioned premise that drives the film has its own logical issues. The idea that these individuals, who are eventually permitted to interact with the outside world, would largely accept their fate as glorified cadavers whose lifespans will be seriously cut short without serious protest or anger is simply untenable. They are not kept in strict isolation; they see and speak to individuals who are much older than they will ever be, even half-heartedly attempting to track down the “originals” from whom they were (presumably) cloned. They demonstrate class awareness and a sense of injustice in determining that those “originals” were likely junkies and whores. In a scenario where the children are kept completely in the dark for the duration of their existence, the premise might hold water, but once Hawkins’ “Guardian” spills the beans, much of what follows requires an unnecessarily extreme suspension of disbelief. 

Fans of Ishiguro’s novel will doubtless want to see how the beloved tome was translated for the screen, and will perhaps enjoy an enhanced appreciation of its emotionally charged content, but Never Let Me Go ultimately feels like a noble misfire. A more fleet-footed director – like Garland’s usual partner Boyle – might have been able to trespass some of the more egregious plot holes, but Romanek is seemingly content to milk the premise for sometimes-affecting, sometimes-forced misery where it should have inspired something considerably more dynamic.

Simon Howell

Written By

Simon is a sometimes writer and podcaster living in Toronto.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tilt Magazine Logo
Pop culture from all angles...

Trending

Crazy Samurai Musashi Review Crazy Samurai Musashi Review

Fantasia 2020: Tak Sakaguchi Takes on an Army in Crazy Samurai Musashi

Film

Goodfellas Anniversary Review Goodfellas Anniversary Review

30 Years Later: Goodfellas Captured Lightning in a Bottle

Film

The Mary Tyler Moore Show The Mary Tyler Moore Show

The Mary Tyler Moore Show at 50

TV

100 Greatest Horror Movie Scenes 100 Greatest Horror Movie Scenes

Greatest Horror Movie Scenes

Film

Horror Movie Scenes Horror Movie Scenes

Greatest Horror Movie Scenes

Film

Fantasia 2020: Tiny Tim: King For a Day is a Moving Look at an American Curiosity

Film

The Legend of Baron To’a The Legend of Baron To’a

Fantasia 2020: The Legend of Baron To’a Exemplifies New Zealand Cinema

Film

Jeremiah Johnson Western Review Jeremiah Johnson Western Review

Jeremiah Johnson is the Most Beautiful Western

Film

Cosmic Candy Cosmic Candy

Fantasia 2020: Cosmic Candy Hides Reality Behind a Quirky Exterior

Film

Great Horror Movie Scenes Great Horror Movie Scenes

Greatest Horror Movie Scenes

Film

Bill and Ted Face the Music Review Bill and Ted Face the Music Review

Bill & Ted Face the Music is a Most Excellent Addition

Film

Greatest Horror Movie Scenes Greatest Horror Movie Scenes

Greatest Horror Movie Scenes

Film

Connect