Connect with us
Zero Dark Thirty
Image: Sony Pictures

Film

Zero Dark Thirty:  The Hunt for Bin Laden and a Heap of Controversy 

For ten years one woman never stopped searching for the most wanted man in history.

Zero Dark Thirty, 10 Years Later

When Zero Dark Thirty arrived in December of 2012, ten years ago this week, it was hailed by critics as perhaps the definitive movie about the post-9/11 years. The film sought to tell the multi-year story that led up to the raid that captured and killed Osama Bin Laden on May 1, 2011, by following first the work of the CIA and then SEAL Team 6’s raid in Abbottabad.

Directed by Kathryn Bigelow and written by Mark Boal, who had collaborated three years earlier on Best Picture winner The Hurt Locker, Zero Dark Thirty portrayed itself as a journalistic look at the hunt for Bin Laden. 

The film stars Jessica Chastain as “Maya,” a composite of several CIA agents who assisted in the hunt for the al-Qaeda leader. She is present for sessions using “enhanced interrogation techniques,” the Bush-era euphemism for torture, and later uses more traditional intelligence to help lead to Bin Laden’s hideout. We also see her pushing CIA brass (led by James Gandolfini, in one of his last roles, as Leon Panetta) to take the action they ultimately did. 

Zero Dark Thirty
Image: Sony Pictures

The film depicted, probably better than any film since, the day-to-day lives of the people tasked with finding Bin Laden, with a long list of fantastic actors  — Jason Clarke, Joel Edgerton, Kyle Chandler, Jennifer Ehle, Harold Perrineau, Edgar Ramirez, Man Duplass — playing CIA and other government functionary roles. 

Zero Dark Thirty was met with massive controversy from the moment it arrived, which has continued to dog it ever since. 

The charges were many: That it was inaccurate. That the film normalized, excused, or even extolled torture for leading directly to Bin Laden’s capture. That the filmmakers were way too close to the CIA, or even that they improperly used classified information. That the film was so bent on being apolitical that it was afraid to say anything positive or negative about the Bush or Obama Administrations. 

There was even another film several years later, The Report, which told the story of the Congressional aide (Adam Driver) who wrote the report about the torture program; that film took several direct shots at Zero Dark Thirty. The Report took the position that not only was torture unspeakably evil but that the functionaries who sold the Bush Administration on it were essentially hucksters who made up their own pseudoscience and got the government to pay them for it. Zero Dark Thirty doesn’t argue exactly that, but it doesn’t quite refute it, either. 

Zero Dark Thirty
Image: Sony Pictures

Some of these criticisms are fairer than others. The film does, indeed, depict torture- a lot of it. But whether that torture led directly to Bin Laden’s capture is actually somewhat ambiguous in the film itself. Zero Dark Thirty is not an outright endorsement of the Bush-Cheney approach to antiterrorism, but it’s not an indictment of it either. And after all, the torture program was stopped when Obama came into office in early 2009, and it didn’t prevent Bin Laden from being captured more than two years later. 

For their part, the filmmakers always claimed that the film was not meant to be a documentary. And some of its critics, led by the always-wrong Glenn Greenwald, saw it fit to trash the film without seeing it. 

It would not be fair to call the film propaganda for any particular party or ideology. I guess the closest it comes to a point of view is in depicting the CIA as competent, but even then, it neither glosses over torture nor is reluctant to bring up the Iraq/WMD subject.  

There’s no doubt, though, that Zero Dark Thirty is a fantastically made film. It has the bearing and style of a thriller, and the third-act raid on the Bin Laden compound, in which the SEALs are led by a pre-Marvel Chris Pratt, is truly great cinema. 

The film was nominated for five Oscars, including Best Picture, although its only win was a tie for Best Sound Editing. It shares with Argo, the film that beat it out for the top Oscar that year, that both are very exciting films about historical events, in which the story isn’t exactly true. 

Written By

Stephen Silver is a journalist and film critic based in the Philadelphia area. He is the co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle and a Rotten Tomatoes-listed critic since 2008, and his work has appeared in New York Press, Philly Voice, The Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tablet, The Times of Israel, and RogerEbert.com. In 2009, he became the first American journalist to interview both a sitting FCC chairman and a sitting host of "Jeopardy" on the same day.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

G20 review: President Viola Davis goes Rambo against Antony Starr’s crypto bro terrorist

Film

Megan Thee Stallion Called Out By Houston Rapper For Allegedly Stealing Her Song

Celebrity

The White Lotus Creator Mike White Responds To Composer’s Controversial Exit

Celebrity

The Weeknd Reveals His New Album “Hurry Up Tomorrow” Was Originally A Film

Celebrity

How Did Havoc End? Unpacking the Shocking Twists in Netflix’s New Tom Hardy Action Movie

Film

22 acts we can’t wait to see at Coachella 2025

Celebrity

Big U Is Considering Asking Donald Trump For Help With His Massive RICO Case

Celebrity

Nelly Wants Court To Impose Sanctions On Ali Jones For Dropped St. Lunatics Lawsuit

Celebrity

NLE Choppa Introduces His New Children’s Book To Memphis Preschoolers With A Read-A-Long

Celebrity

Lorde Announces New Album, ‘Virgin’: ‘100% Written in Blood’

Celebrity

Kali Uchis dating history

Celebrity

Danny Brown Teases “SCARING THE HOES” Volume 2 With JPEGMAFIA

Celebrity

Sheryl Crow on Settling Down but Still Fighting the Power in Nashville: ‘I Call My Representatives Every Single Morning’

Celebrity

The Story of an Extraordinary Woman, Played by an Extraordinary Deneuve

Film

Jena Sims Net Worth: Beyond Fame and Philanthropy

Celebrity

Anthony Edwards Gives A Post-Game Shoutout To His Daughter Amid Ayesha Howard Drama

Celebrity

Connect