Is The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey an Adaptation or a Prequel, or Both?
From the smallest beginnings come the greatest legends.
Revisiting The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
There is an argument to be made that Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy is the best series of films of the naught decade, if not of the new century. And while the massive group of Tolkien scholars and fans can debate the page-by-page honesty of the series ‘til the cows come home, the consensus is usually that while some small changes were made, Jackson got the spirit of the novels right. Nearly ten years after that series ended, Jackson returned with the far more controversial and divisive Hobbit movies. While there is plenty to debate about the quality of the film as a whole, the more interesting debate is how the spirit of the movie poses a larger problem to its quality than any other individual element.
We are all aware of the story; the wizard Gandalf shows up at Bilbo Baggins’ hobbit hole one day and inquires if he would like to join an adventure. While declining at first, Bilbo joins the quest of a group of Dwarves to reclaim their lost kingdom and treasure at the Lonely Mountain from the dragon Smaug who had stolen it years before. If it sounds like a fairy tale that would be because Tolkien wrote it as a fairy tale. This was a story written for children and therefore is filled with the kind of fantastic fairy tale mythos that are characteristic of children’s stories. Encounters with bumbling trolls and riddle contests with deformed cavern dwellers are not wholly serious scenes. They are funny and captivating but still primarily meant for children.
The film, on the other hand, does not always follow this tone. Opening with an extended monologue from Bilbo recounting the story of the dwarves in the Lonely Mountain, Ian Holm’s narration over-top the visuals create a very adult and sometimes scary telling of how Smaug conquered the dwarven kingdom. We are then taken to Gandalf’s invitation and the arrival of the dwarves. This scene is very true to the novel both in execution and tone. It is inviting and childish and funny and it refuses to take itself seriously. Following this though, is the introduction of the orc hunters and their wargs which returns to the adult scary tone from the opening sequence. Even in comparison to similar figures in the Lord of the Rings trilogy, these characters are absolutely hideous and terrifying.
The critical response to Radagast the Brown is also very telling of this conflict. The critics that viewed it from the novel perspective enjoyed Radagast. He was funny and silly and gave kids a character to get them through some of the scarier scenes. From the adult perspective though, he was clearly a distraction. The epic scale of Jackson’s world should not allow for the contrived silliness of Radagast’s antics.
These all present a major problem for the film’s cohesion. Torn between the kind of gravitas championed in The Lord of the Rings and the childhood fantasy of Tolkien’s novel, the film feels almost schizophrenic in its delivery. Jackson himself seems torn between creating a prequel of the high fantasy of his masterpiece and adapting Tolkien’s fairy tale with a high degree of reliability. By not having a cohesive message and tone the viewer will either see a child’s story delivered by a tactless adult or an adult’s story told by a four-year-old.
I saw the former; I was engrossed by the humour and joy of the fairy tale I remember my father reading to me as a child and I was distracted by the adult elements that made the kid in me very uncomfortable. I wanted to see a children’s movie and The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey did not deliver on that level because of Jackson’s grasping at the past. All of the 3D and frame rate problems don’t compare to the problem of a film that doesn’t understand what it is. And while I wish that the two sequels would meet my desires, I’ll bet that Jackson will make them into the kind of high fantasy that much of the critical response seemed to be craving.
— Mynt Marsellus
Editor’s Note: This article was originally published under our old brand, Sound On Sight.Watch The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey