Connect with us
Bones of Crows
Image Courtesy of TIFF

Film

Bones of Crows: A Vital Reminder of Violence and Trauma’s Lingering Pain

Marie Clements’ latest film plunges into the dark history of residential schools that attempted to eradicate Indigenous identity.

TIFF 2022: Bones of Crows Review

Through determination and self-preservation, Aline remains weathered but strong-willed in the face of continued discrimination. A history of trauma shapes who she has become and through Marie Clements’ harrowing portrayal of the impact of residential schools on Cree and other Indigenous peoples, Aline represents resilience under constant assault. Clements’ latest film, Bones of Crows has a very single thought on its mind and attacks racism and prejudices with an equal measure of anger and sadness.

Opening with a cruel joke played on Indigenous slaves by a White man in 1800s Manitoba, Bones of Crows quickly shifts from its stirring thesis statement to the life of Aline (played by Summer Testawich, Grace Dove, and Carla Rae, each during a different period in her life). Torn from her home in the 1930s along with her sister and brother, she is sent to a residential school where she is met with only pain and suffering. One of many dark parts of Canada’s history, residential schools continue to resurface in the news as more and more unmarked graves of children are found that were forced to attend these schools where their identity and culture was stripped from them.

It’s a harrowing subject that Clements handles with care, refusing to look away from the horrors but not leaning into it for shock value. As the film zigzags between moments in Aline’s life, it becomes disorienting but the foundational trauma from her experience at a residential school color every interaction. Moments of violence and despair punctuate an otherwise standard look at the way trauma lingers and finds a way to cripple progress as it reappears. 

Bones of Crows does not restrict its focus to just Aline though, as she encounters many others who have been subject to either similar circumstances or other traumas perpetrated due to their race. Her sister finds herself on the wrong side of the law more often than not, and Aline’s husband finds his past traumas inseparable from his career in the military. Meanwhile, Aline has adapted to a White man’s world, but she’s also remained careful not to stand out too much by avoiding speaking Cree or stepping out of line. Her dreams and ambitions were taken from her long ago and have rendered her invisible as she looks out for her own family and no one else.

Unfortunately, Bones of Crows goes from an initially impressive black-and-white photography to serviceable but unremarkable cinematography. Some shots stand out, but they’re few and far between. In fact, like the photography, the biggest problem with Clements’ film is that it seems composed of moments strung together. It has an autobiographical quality to its structure but its uncanny ability to sell its most harrowing moments is undercut frequently by performances that always feel slightly stilted. It works in the case of Aline and as we see her older it’s much less of a problem, but with others, it’s far more noticeable.

This doesn’t take away from the importance of Bones of Crows and its subject matter, but it does undermine the potency of its delivery. The film culminates in what is essentially an abbreviated recap of the history of residential schools and testimonies from real-life survivors and that helps leave a lasting impression once the credits roll, but Clements’ film is a bit too long-in-the-tooth and through its complete exploration of a survivor it ends up hitting many of the same beats during its runtime. Bones of Crows, like Night Raiders, has the opportunity to teach through its character work and comprehensive understanding of its subject matter; which is why even with its faults, it’s still a vital piece of cinema.

The 47th edition of the Toronto International Film Festival takes place from September 8–18Find all our coverage here.

Written By

Chris is a graduate of Communications from Simon Fraser University and resides in Victoria, British Columbia. Given a pint, he will talk for days about action films, video games, and the works of John Carpenter.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

Falling-Down film review Falling-Down film review

Joel Schumacher’s Falling Down Poses Some Serious Questions

Film

The Big Lebowski The Big Lebowski

25 Years Later: Aggression Will Not Stand in The Big Lebowski

Film

The Academy Awards: The Best Picture Losers The Academy Awards: The Best Picture Losers

50 Best Movies to not Win Best Picture at the Oscars

Film

Martin Scorsese's King of Comedy review Martin Scorsese's King of Comedy review

Rupert Pupkin Lives!: The King of Comedy at 40

Film

Blueback film review Blueback film review

Blueback Doesn’t Dive Deep Enough

Film

Pathaan Pathaan

Pathaan Completes the Westernization of Bollywood

Culture

The Last of Us Left Behind The Last of Us Left Behind

It’s So Hard to Say Goodbye on The Last of Us “Left Behind”

TV

The Last of Us Look for the Light The Last of Us Look for the Light

The Last of Us Season One Ends the Only Way It Knows How with “Look for the Light”

TV

The Last of Us Kin The Last of Us Kin

The Last of Us Finds a Moment of Peace with “Kin”

TV

Ray Liotta’s 10 best movie roles Ray Liotta’s 10 best movie roles

As He Stars in Cocaine Bear, Remembering Ray Liotta’s 10 Best Movie Roles 

Film

CREED III review CREED III review

Creed III is a Triumphant Directorial Debut for Michael B. Jordan

Film

AEW Best shirts and merch AEW Best shirts and merch

“Just a T-Shirt Company”: The Best AEW Shirts (Current Top-Selling Merch)

Wrestling

The Mandalorian Season 2 Phenomenally Flaunts The Potential of Storytelling With Star Wars The Mandalorian Season 2 Phenomenally Flaunts The Potential of Storytelling With Star Wars

The Mandalorian Starts Season 3 with a Good Episode but an Okay Premiere in “The Apostate”

Culture

Brother movie review Brother movie review

Brother is a Well-acted but Overwrought Account of 1990s Scarborough

Film

The Last of Us When We Are in Need The Last of Us When We Are in Need

Everyone’s a Monster In The Last of Us “When We Are in Need”

TV

Inside Movie Review Inside Movie Review

Being Trapped Inside with Willem Dafoe’s Art Thief is (Mostly) Great

Film

Connect