Connect with us
Netflix's The Watcher
Image: Netflix

TV

Netflix’s The Watcher (2022) and Thoughts on Ambiguous TV Mystery Endings

An Ode to The Watcher

The Independent/MSN

The Watcher (2022) is a mystery/thriller series (available on Netflix), based on true events from a 2018 article by Reeves Wiedeman. The show revolves around a couple who had spent just about all their savings on their new house, only to then be mailed alarming letters from “The Watcher.” The show — as in real life — ends unresolved, depicting the main characters watching their own muse from a distance.

Then it cuts to black and explicitly spells it out for us: “The Watcher case remains unsolved.” The End.

Some people didn’t seem too thrilled by that.

The Watcher
Image: Netflix

Something worth remembering

It makes me wonder if ‘based on true events’ is ever a promise to do anything. Or if it’s just part of the entertainment, just the show business chugging along. Interestingly, The Watcher is a tale of two true stories. (1) The Watcher story (which is unsolved), and, (2) the John Graff/John List murders (which is solved). Thing is, most of the audience probably wanted these reversed, at least in fiction. But that’s not what we got.

What we got was an ending that depicted ambiguity. The ambiguity of the ‘true events.’

Ambiguous doesn’t mean bad. We can describe series endings as disappointing, and even frustrating when they retreat just when they are called on to reward. Some endings are confusing when they resolve too little. Other endings we can’t help but call cheap: endings for the sake of. But many of them are also primed for discussion, inviting viewers to make connections or question things one last time. All the messages of a story link together to the bitter end. Let’s call ambiguous endings that feel interactive and expand stories: “open” endings. And those that simply end stories: “clean” endings (whether successful or not).

Skip it

Netflix horror
Image: Netflix

Either way, a greater indicator of success would be if people stayed along for the ride, intrigued enough to see the entire story through. And I look at The Watcher as simply another case of a well-made show about a family and a stalker, albeit with a divisive ending.

Away from the ending, some people look at the show as “campy,” for having “kooky” characters played by a strong cast. How the show could have been tense in the hands of another. I am a pro wrestling fan. I’m not trained to think campy and kooky are bad things, nor that they suggest the absence of tension. So I don’t really know what to say to that.

The Watcher
Image: Netflix

Fittingly frustrating

It was midway through The Watcher that I realized how easily wooed I can be by fictionalized mysteries, thrillers, and horror. Some employ more drama (The Stranger (2020), Two Summers/Twee Zomers (2022), The Perfect Mother/Une Mére Parfaite (2021)). Others, a lot more humor (Anxious People/Folk med ångest (2021), Unsuspicious/Nada Suspeitos (2022), The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Woman in the Window (2022)).

But the endings are almost never my favorite part. (From the list above, I can point to only The Perfect Mother and The Woman in the House… as having standout endings. Both were “clean” in terms of the perpetrator.) And so, despite my enjoyment of the “kooky” mystery and commentary on superficial dreams, I pre-empted the same disappointing finale for The Watcher. But I was wrong. The final sequences — characters essentially being absolved of suspicion — are built on top of the other, like stressed vertebrae. Then, we see Dean; then Nora. The End.

The Watcher Netflix
Image: Netflix

Maybe the problem isn’t so much “clean” versus “open.” Or true events versus fiction. It could just be the problem of a yes-or-no question translated into a sub-genre of fiction. The problem and allure of maybe.

As in maybe mysteries are meant to disappoint.

The Watcher
Image: Netflix
Written By

Harvey Garcia is sometimes a poet and freelance writer from Manila; always going to pop for a butterfly suplex, and a good line cut.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

Carrick and Fernandes leave at 12:30 am as Man Utd captain slammed and boss faces sack

Celebrity

Barry Keoghan Gets £4,500 Cosmetic Treatment Amid Appearance Speculation

Celebrity

Bobby Kennedy’s granddaughter, Kyle Kennedy, dies at 42

Celebrity

Patina Miller Reveals Daughter, 9, Is Following Her Broadway Career

Celebrity

Savannah Chrisley Warned About Her Romance With Jason Galanis Could Be a Rocky Ride

Celebrity

Tess Daly and Ex-Vernon Kay Put On United Front at Daughter Phoebe’s 22nd Birthday

Celebrity

Nick‍‍‍ Knowles announces BBC doesn’t plan to revive DIY SOS in its original ‍‍‍format.

Celebrity

Nicolas‍‍‍ Cage’s Enigmatic Pyramid Tomb in a New Orleans ‍‍‍Cemetery

Celebrity

Tom Arnold reacts to ex-Roseanne Barr defending him 30 years later: ‘Hell just froze over!’

Celebrity

Meghan ‘deeply distressed’ by abuse image claims against father Thomas; letter sent to Met 2018

Celebrity

Jack‍‍‍ Lowden, the Bond fan favourite, is now considering a career as a director. ‍‍‍

Celebrity

Lou Teasdale Alleges Girls Were Silenced With NDAs Before Being Left Alone With Famous Men

Celebrity

Jack Nicholson’s friend confirms reclusive life: ‘He’s disappeared.’

Celebrity

Will Smith Enjoys Australia Reunion With Ex-Wife Sheree Zampino

Celebrity

George Stroumboulopoulos Gets Candid About His Mother’s Advice and Special Bond With a Horse

Celebrity

Luciana Damon’s Courageous Red Carpet Comeback After Secret Brain Surgery

Celebrity

Connect