Connect with us
The Guilty
Image Courtesy of TIFF


TIFF 2021: The Guilty is a Thrilling, Unnecessary Remake

Jake Gyllenhaal gives an intense performance in Antoine Fuqua’s remake of the 2018 Danish thriller, The Guilty. With a few smart changes, this Pizzolatto-penned remake offers more pulp than emotion.

The Guilty Review

Remaking the 2018 Danish thriller of the same name almost beat-for-beat, Antoine Fuqua’s The Guilty is still a riveting film that makes some slight changes and is bolstered by a delightfully unhinged Jake Gyllenhaal performance. With a script written by True Detective’s Nic Pizzolatto, this single-location suspense film’s pulpy plot makes up for its inability to conjure dramatic weight with its constant tension.

Set over the span of a night while California’s forests are burning up from wildfires, response teams like the police, firefighters, and ambulances are all spread thin. So when 911 operator and former police officer, Joe Baylor (Gyllenhaal), receives a call from a woman named Emily Lighton (Riley Keough) who appears to be being abducted, his resources are limited on how he can help. With no license plate information and a city already on high alert from the fires, it’s difficult to near-impossible to ask for police to go on a manhunt with almost no details.

This sets in motion a white-knuckle thrill ride as Joe frantically calls in any favor he can, using his knowledge as a police officer and resourcefulness to try to locate and save her before it’s too late. However, what makes this version of The Guilty different is its use of the California wildfires in the backdrop. Take those out and the roadblocks seem a little less sensible, but with few details on the vehicle and an extremely busy night ahead, there’s a tension created in the real world that mirrors Joe’s own anxiety.

However, almost every other plot point in The Guilty is exactly the same as the original Danish film. So all of the pulp that was there before is here again, and perhaps even more exacerbated by the night not being a normal night to begin with. Everything is on fire metaphorically and literally, and when twists start revealing themselves in the screenplay it becomes a barrage of absurdity. Is this literally the worst night of this man’s life? 

The Guilty
Image via TIFF

Coincidentally, it all takes place the night before he is about to face trial for a crime not disclosed until near the very end of The Guilty. It’s the source of Joe’s anxiety and his constant dependence on his inhaler. It’s also where the film has to reckon with why he’s going to court – something which the film believes to be its ace in the hole but doesn’t actually want to wrestle with what that means.

Instead, it’s just another twist that lets Gyllenhaal flex his acting chops. He gives another spectacular performance, rife with so many nuances and mood swings that it’s hard not to applaud such dizzying theatrics. He understands full well that the main draw of Fuqua’s film is its pulp, and Gyllenhaal has made it very clear that he loves pulp based on some of his previous roles. Where the film falters in its attempt to incorporate a sense of drama and a man reckoning with his own guilt, Gyllenhaal does what he can and it is just strong enough to not feel lost in the suspense.

The Guilty is an easy 90 minutes to burn through. Fuqua employs so much tension in such a short period of time that finding time to breathe becomes a chore. Which reflects what’s going on in Joe’s head, making the performance from Gyllenhaal even more intense. If nothing else, The Guilty will keep you on the edge of your seat, especially if you’ve never seen the original film. If you have though, there’s not much more here that warrants a remake even with some of its smart changes.

The 46th edition of the Toronto International Film Festival, taking place September 9–18, is tailored to fit the moment, with physical screenings and drive-ins, digital screenings, virtual red carpets, press conferences, and industry talks. Find all our coverage here.

Written By

Chris is a graduate of Communications from Simon Fraser University and resides in Toronto, Ontario. Given a pint, he will talk for days about action films, video games, and the works of John Carpenter.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pop Culture From All Angles

Sordid Cinema Podcast


150 Greatest Horror Movies of the 20th Century 150 Greatest Horror Movies of the 20th Century

150 Greatest Horror Movies


TIFF 2021: Where is Anne Frank is a Lovely, Creative Re-Imagining


I Purple You: An In-Depth Look at the BTS ARMY and Their Stories- Part One


Barbara Stanwyck Barbara Stanwyck

The Career of Barbara Stanwyck: The Dame from Brooklyn


The Cultural Significance of BTS’s Appointment as “Special Presidential Envoys for Future Generations and Culture”


Midnight Mass Midnight Mass

Midnight Mass Is A Grand, Grotesque Horror Masterpiece


BTS at the United Nations 2021: A Historical Moment Watched by Over A Million


Coldplay x BTS My Universe Music Video Review: A Surprising Sci-Fi Spectacular


Coldplay X BTS’s “My Universe” Review: A Collaboration that Brings Together the Best of Both Musical Worlds


Seinfeld Season 05 Inside Looks 'The Marine Biologist' Seinfeld Season 05 Inside Looks 'The Marine Biologist'

Seinfeld’s Greatest Scene: “The Marine Biologist” Monologue


Hulu only murders in the building poster Hulu only murders in the building poster

Why You Should Be Watching Only Murders in the Building


Seinfeld Fake Movies Seinfeld Fake Movies

Ranking the Seinfeld Fake Movies