Connect with us
The Report film review
Image via Amazon Studios

Film

The Report is the Festival’s Most Overrated Film

Truth Matters

Sundance 2019: The Report

The standard joke among film critics is that many of the films they fall all over themselves to praise at Sundance will end up having mediocre, flash-in-the-pan releases once the wider critical community gets a glimpse. Usually, those films are pleasant but forgettable dramedies, but for the 2019 festival, a super-serious drama with an impressive pedigree takes the cake. The Report (formerly The Torture Report) attempts to make sense of the United States’ shameful embrace of torture in the days and weeks following the September 11 attacks, and it demands to be seen due to the urgency of its story and the moral consequences of ignoring it. Yet as important as its story and the facts contained within are, The Report is a work of incredibly shoddy filmmaking, only barely rescued by a good-not-great performance from Adam Driver. Such a necessary reckoning with history deserves a totally assured film, not the flimsy premium cable-quality work that writer and director Scott Z. Burns has created.

Adam Driver leads an impressive ensemble cast as Senate staffer Daniel Jones, who works for California Senator Dianne Feinstein (Annette Bening) in the later years of the Bush administration and the early years of the Obama administration to craft a definitive report on the use of torture (or “enhanced interrogation techniques”) against suspected terrorist detainees by the CIA. As the political tides turn and the administration’s transition, he faces unexpected roadblocks from the Deputy National Security Advisor and eventual Chief of Staff to Barack Obama, Denis McDonough (Jon Hamm).

Burns’ marshaling of the historical record is impressive, and The Report is packed with scenes that will make many viewers react with disgust regardless of their political affiliations and beliefs. Because of that, I have no hesitation in recommending everyone see the film if only to better understand the workings of their own government. I consider myself a politics junkie, yet there was considerable information in the film that was new to me and broadened my understanding of the events. At a Q & A following the film’s Sundance premiere, Burns asked how many audience members still believed that torture worked (only one man raised his hand) before revealing that somewhere near half of all Americans believe so. The film is essential, if only as a corrective to years of misinformation.

The Report film review
Image: Amazon Studios

Unfortunately, despite the importance of the events he dramatizes, Burns has crafted a film that fails to live up to their significance. Though he has worked extensively as a screenwriter and has written multiple acclaimed films for his longtime collaborator Steven Soderbergh, this is Burns’ first feature as a director, and it shows. The man has no visual flair whatsoever — nary a shot has any kind of interesting composition, and he and cinematographer Eigil Bryld seem constrained by the omnipresence of fluorescent lighting in government buildings. (It’s worth noting that many of the scenes in Paul Thomas Anderson’s Phantom Thread were shot under fluorescent lighting, so the harsh lights need not limit a real visual artist.) Soderbergh is a producer on the film; one wonders what a true visual stylist like him might have made of the film. Even when Burns does try to ape Soderbergh’s style he fails miserably. Multiple flashback scenes of the CIA immediately after 9/11 are shot on a lower quality digital stock and use a yellowish filter the color of curdled milk, mimicking the different color schemes Soderbergh used to distinguish storylines in Traffic (2000). The intensely ugly scenes do what they’re supposed to do, i.e., show that they’re happening at a different time, but they do it in a frustratingly obtuse way. Soderbergh was shooting on warm celluloid, not the harsh digital that Burns uses, creating a different visual and emotional sense. If a color scheme change is necessary to show that a scene is a flashback, something has gone wrong with the storytelling.

Burns has never been the most lyrical screenwriter, but his words have always been appropriate and workmanlike. Here, his dialogue reads more like an info dump, a way to present the most information possible in the fewest number of words. Nobody really speaks like a human being in the film, and there’s no sense that they have lives outside their work. There’s also an annoying tendency to restate major points just to make sure the audience gets it, even though these characters would never have spoken so bluntly about subjects they were all familiar with.

The Report
Image: Amazon Studios

If there’s a saving grace to the film, it’s the often strong cast. Adam Driver is fueled by a justifiable sense of outrage that makes him intriguing, even when the words he’s been given to speak are banal. Bening does a striking impression of Feinstein that will ring true to anyone who watches much cable news. And Hamm is appropriately slimy as McDonough, who pretends to be on the side of the good guys while doing his best to quash the investigation. (Strangely, despite using makeup and wardrobe to make Bening look eerily like Feinstein, Hamm’s hair wasn’t even dyed to match McDonough’s recognizable salt and pepper.)

An honest accounting of Burns’ failures as a filmmaker feels a bit like castigating him for his good intentions. After all, as a work of popular history, The Report is necessary and probably should be seen by most Americans. But it’s still an immense failure that the movie’s filmmaking is so out of step with the story’s necessity. It’s better to have this disappointing reckoning exist, rather than to have the story locked away from the general public. But we deserved better.

The Sundance Film Festival runs from January 24 – February 3. Visit the official website for more information.

Watch The Report

Now Streaming

Written By

Brian Marks is Sordid Cinema's Lead Film Critic. His writing has appeared in The Village Voice, LA Weekly, The Los Angeles Times, and Ampersand. He's a graduate of USC's master's program in Specialized Arts Journalism. You can find more of his writing at InPraiseofCinema.com. Best film experience: driving halfway across the the country for a screening of Jean-Luc Godard's "King Lear." Totally worth it.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

Lauryn Hill Joins Drake On Stage During Night 1 Of Wireless Festival

Celebrity

Taylor Rooks Seemingly Responds To Drake’s Mention In Unreleased Song From “ICEMAN” Livestream

Celebrity

Jurassic World Rebirth review: Scarlett Johansson and Jonathan Bailey help the franchise roar back to life

Film

Fat Joe accused of sex acts with minors in $20 million lawsuit filed by former hype man, rapper denies allegations

Celebrity

15 Best Military Movies Of All Time, Ranked

Film

Lil Wayne “Tha Carter VI” Review

Celebrity

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Season 3 Review: The Best Trek In Decades Doesn’t Miss A Beat

Film

Mello Buckzz’s Boyfriend Shot-&-Killed During Her Mixtape Release Party

News

Tyler Perry Pops Out At Beyonce Show In Paris Amid Sexual Assault Lawsuit

Celebrity

The Best Albums of 2025 (So Far)

Film

‘Christy’ Review: Brothers Estranged by the Care System Rebuild Their Bond in a Moving Irish Crowdpleaser

Film

Sabrina Carpenter unveils new album art ‘approved by God’ after controversy over original’s suggestive imagery

Celebrity

Trillian, Busta Rhymes’s Son, Prepares To Inherit The Throne: On NLE Choppa Collab, Lyrically Sparring With His Dad & The Significance Of Lil Wayne’s “10,000 Bars”

Celebrity

Eminem’s Stalker Gets Lengthy Prison Sentence For Home Invasion

News

Jameela Jamil Net Worth: Actress, Advocate, and Influencer

Celebrity

YNW Melly’s Family Shows Up To Support Him At Court Hearing

Celebrity

Connect