Connect with us
Lady of the Manor review
Image: Lionsgate

Film

Lady of the Manor is a Mediocre Culture Clash Comedy

Lady of the Manor is a wildly misconceived comedy, which fails to draw laughs out of a premise that isn’t that strong, to begin with. But the worst thing about the film is that it wastes the talents of a half-dozen talented and performances. 

I’m always excited when Melanie Lynskey appears in a movie. And Judy Greer. And Justin Long. And Ryan Phillippe. And Luis Guzman. And even Bobby Ewing himself, Patrick Duffy. They’re all are in Lady of the Manor, but none are given a chance to do anything they’re especially good at. 

The movie was directed by Long, the “I’m a Mac” actor, along with his brother Christian; the two co-wrote the film. It’s one of those comedies in which the concept is bad, but the jokes are somehow even worse. 

The high concept here is not one of the better ones among recent comedies. Melanie Lynskey plays Hannah, a stoner layabout who works for a weed delivery service. Phillippe plays the failson of a Southern patriarch (Duffy), suddenly put in charge of the manor when his dad decides to run for office; the other third of the love triangle is Long, playing a nerdish local historian. 

The plot begins with an inciting incident that doesn’t make a lick of sense: Hannah delivers weed to the wrong house, a teenager answers the door, she’s arrested for soliciting sex from a minor, and then has to register as a sex offender. That she’s innocent, and that the teenager wasn’t actually a minor, doesn’t seem to matter. 

That whole sex offender thing, in addition to being wildly incongruous with all of the rest of the movie’s humor, is used mostly as a pretext for her needing to get a new job. That results in her being hired at a grand old Savannah manor to give tours, while in character as the 19th-century lady of the manor- a job that, inexplicably, requires her to live in the house. 

But then, the lady herself (Greer) appears to her as a ghost. 

Lady of the Manor
Image: Lionsgate

They bicker at first, mostly about things like cursing and Hannah’s lack of ladylike propriety, but eventually begin to bond, in order to rewrite a historical wrong. Left unanswered is why the ghost never appeared at any time in the intervening 150 years to right the wrong previously. 

Then there’s the fraught racial and historical stuff naturally involved in a story like this. The estate is always called a “manor” and not a “plantation,”  and the script makes it clear that  Lady Wadsworth died in 1875- i.e., after the Civil War. The Lady is also retconned as something of a secret progressive, leading to a climax that leads to a racial wrong being righted. But I don’t think the word “slavery” is mentioned at any point. 

I love Melanie Lynskey as a performer, but she’s very much miscast here. I’m all for more roles for women over 40 in general and for Lynskey specifically, but it doesn’t make any sense for this character to be that age. Greer isn’t especially a natural fit for the ghost role either, and Phillippe has exactly one note to play as a douchebag who’s pretty much playing Jon Hamm’s part from Bridesmaids

It’s great to see Patrick Duffy, is a rare movie role, although it’s a tiny role that likely took about two days of his time. And I’m not exactly sure why it was necessary to cast someone as talented as Luis Guzman in the nothing part of a bartender. 

Please, Hollywood- start putting the people in this movie into better ones!

Written By

Stephen Silver is a journalist and film critic based in the Philadelphia area. He is the co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle and a Rotten Tomatoes-listed critic since 2008, and his work has appeared in New York Press, Philly Voice, The Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tablet, The Times of Israel, and RogerEbert.com. In 2009, he became the first American journalist to interview both a sitting FCC chairman and a sitting host of "Jeopardy" on the same day.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

Apple 1984 Super Bowl Ad Apple 1984 Super Bowl Ad

A Look Back At The Most Famous Super Bowl Commercial 1984 Directed by Ridley Scott

TV

Greatest-Super-Bowl-Commercials-of-All-Time Greatest-Super-Bowl-Commercials-of-All-Time

A History of The Greatest Super Bowl Commercials of All Time

TV

Greatest Royal Rumble Matches of All time Greatest Royal Rumble Matches of All time

Greatest Royal Rumble Matches

Wrestling

The Best Romantic Comedies The Best Romantic Comedies

Happy Valentine’s Day: Here are the 50 Best Romantic Comedies

Film

best Super Bowl halftime shows in history best Super Bowl halftime shows in history

The 15 Best Super Bowl Halftime Shows in History 

TV

Greatest Romantic Comedies Greatest Romantic Comedies

Happy Valentine’s Day: Here are the 50 Best Romantic Comedies

Film

The Best TV Shows That Premiered After A Super Bowl The Best TV Shows That Premiered After A Super Bowl

The Best TV Shows That Premiered After A Super Bowl

TV

Quentin Tarantino’s New Book Cinema Speculation, is a Groovy Read Quentin Tarantino’s New Book Cinema Speculation, is a Groovy Read

Quentin Tarantino’s New Book Cinema Speculation is a Groovy Read

Culture

The Last of Us Infected The Last of Us Infected

The Last of Us Looks for Love in a Hopeless Place with “Infected”

TV

Hear Me Out Hear Me Out

Hear Me Out Never Finds Its Own Voice

Film

Kaleidoscope Kaleidoscope

Kaleidoscope (2023): How the Newest Hypnotic Netflix Toy Stumbles with its Unique Format

TV

Bill Nighy is a Living Marvel in This Kurosawa Remake

Culture

The Last of Us When You're Lost in the Darkness The Last of Us When You're Lost in the Darkness

The Last of Us Begins with the Bleak, Familiar “When You’re Lost in the Darkness”

TV

Sundance 2023: The Eight Must-See Films at the Festival

Culture

WWE Royal Rumble 1992 WWE Royal Rumble 1992

Why the 1992 WWE Royal Rumble Match is Still The Best

Culture

When It Melts movie review When It Melts movie review

When It Melts Continues an Important Conversation with Unflinching Pathos

Culture

Connect