Connect with us
'The Goldfinch' is unfocused, overlong, and plagued by jarring shifts in tone. This wildly ambitious literary adaptation is a big whiff.


‘The Goldfinch’ is Overlong and Incoherent

‘The Goldfinch’ is unfocused, overlong, and plagued by jarring shifts in tone. This wildly ambitious literary adaptation is a big whiff.

With The Goldfinch, we officially have fall’s first failed awards bait. Based on the popular, Pulitzer Prize-winning 2013 novel by Donna Tartt, this a wildly ambitious literary adaptation that just plain whiffs completely. The Goldfinch is unfocused, overlong, and plagued by wild and jarring shifts in tone. Though it debuted at the Toronto International Film Festival, where it seems like everything this year has gotten rapturous reviews and instant Oscar buzz, The Goldfinch is the clear exception. 

Tartt’s novel, by all indications, is not the sort of thing that’s easily adaptable to the screen, and that’s a big part of the problem — although by no means the only one. Director John Crowley made 2015’s wonderful Brooklyn, but he appears in over his head here, while screenwriter Peter Straughan — whose credits include Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy and The Snowman — doesn’t appear to have been able to make heads or tails of the book. 

Ridiculously overlong at nearly 150 minutes, The Goldfinch has a somewhat convoluted structure that goes back and forth in time between the childhood and adulthood of protagonist Theo Decker (played, respectively, by Oakes Fegley and Ansel Elgort, who don’t look much alike aside from both wearing glasses.) When he’s a kid, Theo’s mother is killed in a bombing at a New York City art museum, and in the chaos afterward, Theo is handed the titular painting, a valuable 17th-century work by Carel Fabritius. Orphaned following his mother’s death, he’s sent to live with a wealthy society family (led by Nicole Kidman), and befriends both an antique shop owner (Jeffrey Wright) and his ward — the niece of the man who gave him the painting (Aimee Laurence as a girl, Ashleigh Cummings as an adult). 

The Goldfinch also has a long middle section in which a young Theo is taken to Las Vegas by his estranged, ne’er-do-well father (Luke Wilson) and his air-headed, sunbathing girlfriend (an underused and laughably miscast Sarah Paulson), and befriends a Russian classmate named Boris (Finn Wolfhard, from Stranger Things and the first IT movie), who introduces him to drugs. Boris is played as an adult by Aneurin Barnard, who acts like he’s channeling Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury. Contemporary scenes see the adult Theo as a suit-wearing, alcoholic pill-popper, obviously suffering PTSD after the bombing and his mother’s death, and caught up in incongruous criminal intrigue involving the painting and bogus antiques. 

This was all probably much more sensical on the page, but here it feels like four different movies mashed together. What, ultimately, is this story about? The legacy of childhood trauma? The importance of the integrity of public art? How every boy needs his mother? Even more than the subject matter, The Goldfinch‘s tone is just all over the place. 

Elgort doesn’t help, with a charisma-free, mopey, empty-suit performance. The two incarnations of his character are in just about every frame of the film, but there still isn’t much sense given by the end of who this guy is or why we’re supposed to care about him. Kidman is just fine in a somewhat underwritten role, but the normally capable Denis O’Hare for some reason plays his character — an art collector who threatens Theo — as a cartoonish, mustache-twirling villain. And I won’t say who, but the most interesting character in the movie exits early on. 

There’s a bit of Moonlight vibe here, as we see two boys who had an intimate encounter as kids have an awkward reunion as adults, but The Goldfinch doesn’t handle it nearly as well as Barry Jenkins’ Oscar winner did. The ending is especially terrible, as the film briefly turns into Reservoir Dogs in its third act, complete with a heist and shootout. Then, all of a sudden, the plot resolves itself with a laughable deus ex machina. 

This fall is going to have a lot of films that will kick off arguments, but it’s unlikely there will be much disagreement that The Goldfinch doesn’t work, at all. 

Written By

Stephen Silver is a journalist and film critic based in the Philadelphia area. He is the co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle and a Rotten Tomatoes-listed critic since 2008, and his work has appeared in New York Press, Philly Voice, The Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tablet, The Times of Israel, and In 2009, he became the first American journalist to interview both a sitting FCC chairman and a sitting host of "Jeopardy" on the same day.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



2001: A Space Odyssey 2001: A Space Odyssey

2001: Clarke and Kubrick’s Odyssey of Discovery


The Best Movies of 1973 The Best Movies of 1973

The Golden Year of Movies: 1973



Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse Is a Dazzling Web of Unbridled Creativity


The Zone of Interest The Zone of Interest

Cannes 2023: Jonathan Glazer’s The Zone of Interest is a Manicured Vision of Hell


Jeanne Du Barry review Jeanne Du Barry review

Cannes 2023: Maïwenn’s Great Hair Goes to Great Lengths in Jeanne Du Barry


Asteroid City: A Gimmicky Vanity Project Asteroid City: A Gimmicky Vanity Project

Cannes 2023: Wes Anderson’s Asteroid City is a Gimmicky Vanity Project


Black Flies Gripping Black Flies Gripping

Cannes 2023: Black Flies— Gripping Descent into the Underbelly of New York’s Urban Misery 


Four Daughters Four Daughters

Cannes 2023: Four Daughters: A Family’s Journey From Goth to Niqab


La Passion de Dodin Bouffant: La Passion de Dodin Bouffant:

La Passion de Dodin Bouffant: Surfeit Cooking Drama Most Inane Film at Cannes


The Mother Jennifer Lopez and Lucy Paez The Mother Jennifer Lopez and Lucy Paez

Jennifer Lopez’s The Mother is Eerily Similar to Enough, But That’s Not a Bad Thing


The Matrix Reloaded The Matrix Reloaded

20 Years Later: The Matrix Reloaded was Underwhelming, but Still Underrated


Godzilla 1998 Godzilla 1998

Godzilla at 25: When Hollywood Made a Manhattan Monster Movie, with Disastrous Results


Starling Girl Starling Girl

The Starling Girl is a fine exploration of love, religion, and coming of age


Discovery channel Discovery channel

The Head-Scratching Moves Discovery Has Been Making


Le Retour: Controversially Mediocre French Contender Director: Catherine Corsini Le Retour: Controversially Mediocre French Contender Director: Catherine Corsini

Cannes 2023: Le Retour is a Controversially Mediocre French Contender


Touch of Evil - Orson Welles Touch of Evil - Orson Welles

Cursed Genius: Orson Welles’ Touch of Evil