Connect with us
David Fincher's Mank Netflix review

Film

Fincher’s Mank is a beautiful disappointment

Follows screenwriter Herman J. Mankiewicz’s tumultuous development of Orson Welles’ iconic masterpiece Citizen Kane (1941).

Unfortunately, Mank lands with something of a thud…

It’s a biopic of Herman J. Mankiewicz, the screenwriter of Citizen Kane, and delves deeply into many of the controversies about that film that have festered for nearly eight decades. Plus, the film has been made in sumptuous black and white, meant to evoke the look and feel of Citizen Kane itself. Netflix has even renamed itself “Netflix International Pictures” in the movie’s promotion. 

Unfortunately, Mank lands with something of a thud. Yes, it looks absolutely beautiful, features fine turns by some talented actors, and very much captures the spirit of the old Hollywood studio system. 

David Fincher's Mank Netflix review

But the film’s storytelling is somewhat thin. The screenplay, polished by Eric Roth from that of the elder Fincher, doesn’t have much of a through-line.  The film just jumps around Mankiewicz’s life without particularly having anything to say about him as a man or as a writer, except that he was an alcoholic, who probably deserved more credit for that famous film than history has granted him. 

But even in its dealing with Citizen Kane, it doesn’t add much to the general understanding of one of the more litigated controversies in the history of showbiz. 

Mank goes back and forth through the life of Mankiewicz, showing us his early life on the studio lot, with a gang of other famous writers that included Ben Hecht (Jeff Harms) and his brother Joe (Tom Pelphrey) who would go on to direct All About Eve. We also see Mank’s involvement with Upton Sinclair’s socialist campaign for governor of California in 1934, and eventually his writing of Kane, and his bitter battles with Orson Welles (Tom Burke) over credit. 

David Fincher's Mank Netflix review

The film’s best scenes depict the friendship between Mank and Marion Davies (Amanda Seyfried), the actress mistress of William Randolph Hearst (Charles Dance). Seyfried’s turn is the deepest depiction we’ve ever seen on screen of Davies, although the film makes Mank’s wife Sara (Tuppence Middleton) little more than a nagging, long-suffering-wife cliche. 

Oldman is fine, clearly knowing that he won an Oscar by scenery-chewing and psychical transformation in Darkest Hour, tries again here, playing Mankiewicz at several different ages, although half-drunk most of the time regardless. A few actors, like Dance as Hearst, Arliss Howard as Louis B. Mayer, Ferdinand Kingsley as Irving Thalberg and Toby Leonard Moore as David O. Selznick, get to have some fun playing legendary moguls. 

Even the Citizen Kane stuff has been hashed out many times before, although typically with Welles as the protagonist and/or hero. That was the case with RKO 281, the HBO movie from 1999 in which Liev Schreiber played Welles, John Malkovich was Mankiewicz, Melanie Griffith played Davies and James Cromwell was Hearst. That film, which was one of the most touted unproduced scripts in Hollywood for many years, but ended up being made for television by little-known director Benjamin Ross, provided a more compelling look at the subject matter than Mank, a passion project by one of the best working filmmakers. 

Fincher spent his six years between films producing TV shows, some of which came to fruition (like Mindhunter) and others that didn’t, while also pursuing some nonstarter movies, like a sequel to World War Z. Despite the misfire- and his announcement that he’s making a not-so-promising miniseries about cancel culture- he remains a superlative filmmaker who is capable of greatness. Mank, however, was a big swing, one that has unfortunately missed. 

Written By

Stephen Silver is a journalist and film critic based in the Philadelphia area. He is the co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle and a Rotten Tomatoes-listed critic since 2008, and his work has appeared in New York Press, Philly Voice, The Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tablet, The Times of Israel, and RogerEbert.com. In 2009, he became the first American journalist to interview both a sitting FCC chairman and a sitting host of "Jeopardy" on the same day.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

NBA YoungBoy Gifts Yaya Mayweather A Lamborghini Truck For Her Birthday

Celebrity

Dave Shapiro, Sound Talent Group Co-Founder and Music Agent, Dies in San Diego Plane Crash

Celebrity

Wale Debuts Eye-Catching Nike GT Future Colorway At Got Sole

Celebrity

Kash Doll Staunchly Defends Her Man Za’Darius Smith Against Cheating Allegations

Celebrity

Honey Don’t! Review: Margaret Qualley Sizzles In Ethan Coen’s Moody, Unabashedly Queer Noir

Celebrity

New Kwaito Star Captain Faces Heat Over Mampintsha Comparisons

Culture

Logan Paul’s Boxing Journey: A Look at His Fights and Results

Culture

Demi Lovato marries singer-songwriter Jordan ‘Jutes’ Lutes in California wedding

Celebrity

Doechii Rocks the Edge — 100 Stories Above New York — With Short But Spicy Set

Celebrity

Celebrities Mentioned During Sean “Diddy” Combs Trial

Culture

Ghostface Killah Sets Long-Awaited Classic “Supreme Clientele” Sequel Release Date & It’s Closer Than You Think

Celebrity

Kendrick Lamar Beats Drake For Album Of The Year At The BET Awards

Celebrity

Zion Williamson Responds To Lawsuit For Alleged Sexual Assault & Kidnapping

Celebrity

Olympic Gold Medalist Tom Daley on His New Documentary, Being a ‘Sounding Board’ for Closeted Queer Athletes and Why Tom Holland Should Play Him in a Movie

Celebrity

Joshua Jackson Asks for Emergency Custody Dispute Because of Daughter’s New School

Culture

The 10 Scariest Horror Movies Of 2024, Ranked

Film

Connect