Connect with us
Savage State


Fantasia 2020: Savage State Is Visually Striking, but Dull

David Perrault’s Savage State should be a great addition to modern Western canon. A sprawling, slow-burn adventure, the film follows a family of wealthy French settlers on an arduous journey to escape the chaos of the American Civil War. Against the backdrop of the desolate midwestern wilds and spurred on by the tense circumstances of their flight, the family’s unspoken tensions soon begin to break the surface, old wounds reopening under the harsh sunlight. All the ingredients are there, waiting to coalesce into something greater than the sum of its parts. And yet, that never quite happens. Despite some strong individual elements, the film never quite gels, and as a result, often feels flat and unremarkable.

First, the good. The film is quite often gorgeous to look at, with early scenes in particular sumptuously lit by the amber light candles and fireplaces. The imagery is often striking, making full use of the magnificent desolation of the setting in a way that eschews the grandeur and myth-making of classical westerns, but also the grit and grime of more revisionist fare. Full marks should go to cinematographer Christophe Duchange, who emerges as the film’s clear MVP.

But then there’s…well, everything else. In terms of script, Savage State has an interesting hook, and plenty of fertile ground that could be used to explore themes including but not limited to racism, the bonds of family, the myth of the romantic western hero and American colonialism. But the film remains maddeningly shallow throughout, rarely functioning as more than a self-actualization narrative for our lead, youngest daughter Esther. Esther, her family, and their hard-bitten escort Victor (who also emerges as Ether’s love interest) rarely feel like much more than stock characters. Esther is the melancholy thinker of the family, sister Madeleine the frail, sick one, and other sister Justine admits outright to feeling that she has no identity outside of caring for Madeleine. Victor, meanwhile, is the hard-edged cowboy we’ve all seen numerous times before, gruff and grim, living in fear of the day when the encroaching railroad renders him obsolete. 

Savage State

Things get somewhat interesting with our main villain, a female outlaw named Bettie who seems intent on killing and/or bedding Victor. Of all the cast, Armelle Abibou seems to be giving it the most gusto, playing Bettie as a violent madwoman who does creepy dances and talks to herself. Bettie is also followed around by a gang of nameless enforcers, who warrant mentioning just for how weird and out of place they feel. They never speak, and all spend the entire film wearing burlap sack masks. They hover around menacingly, and later on, take to walking calmly into firefights like they don’t know how bullets work. They feel like the villains of a far more horror-centric movie who wandered onto the wrong set, perhaps a Western spin on The Strangers. They’re one of the more interesting elements of the film, but most of that comes from the fact that we have no idea what their deal is. Mystery, as always, is more intriguing than the rote and expected.

And that’s what the rest of the film is, by and large. It rarely surprises, only really zigging when you expect it to zag once at the very end. It feels mostly dull and lifeless, missing a certain crucial spark to galvanize it into something more. What is that spark, though? A more clever and insightful script? Better chemistry between the cast? A soundtrack that doesn’t recycle the same warbling, amelodic tune for every single dramatic moment? All of the above, maybe? Even that lovely cinematography begins to ring hollow, looking almost too polished and untextured when we switch from the moody lighting of interiors to the flat light of the outdoors.

Savage State

Savage State is one of those films that doesn’t have anything, in particular, holding it back, no single flaw that cripples the film as a whole. Rather, it’s several smaller flaws and a certain missing something that keeps the film from being much more than simply fine.

The Fantasia International Film Festival’s virtual event is composed of scheduled live screenings, panels, and workshops, taking place from August 20th to September 2nd, 2020. For more information, visit the Fantasia Film Festival website.

Written By

Beginning as a co-host on a Concordia TV film show before moving on to chief film nerd at, Thomas is now bringing his knowledge of pop-culture nerdery to Sordid Cinema. Thomas is a Montrealer born and raised, and an avid consumer of all things pop-cultural and nerdy. While his first love is film, he has also been known to dabble in comics, videogames, television, anime and more. You can support his various works on his Patreon, at You can also like the Tom Watches Movies Facebook page to see all his work on Goombastomp and elsewhere.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pop Culture From All Angles

Sordid Cinema Podcast


150 Greatest Horror Movies of the 20th Century 150 Greatest Horror Movies of the 20th Century

150 Greatest Horror Movies


TIFF 2021: Where is Anne Frank is a Lovely, Creative Re-Imagining


I Purple You: An In-Depth Look at the BTS ARMY and Their Stories- Part One


Barbara Stanwyck Barbara Stanwyck

The Career of Barbara Stanwyck: The Dame from Brooklyn


The Cultural Significance of BTS’s Appointment as “Special Presidential Envoys for Future Generations and Culture”


Midnight Mass Midnight Mass

Midnight Mass Is A Grand, Grotesque Horror Masterpiece


BTS at the United Nations 2021: A Historical Moment Watched by Over A Million


Coldplay x BTS My Universe Music Video Review: A Surprising Sci-Fi Spectacular


Coldplay X BTS’s “My Universe” Review: A Collaboration that Brings Together the Best of Both Musical Worlds


Seinfeld Season 05 Inside Looks 'The Marine Biologist' Seinfeld Season 05 Inside Looks 'The Marine Biologist'

Seinfeld’s Greatest Scene: “The Marine Biologist” Monologue


Q-Force Season 1 Review Q-Force Season 1 Review

Q-Force: They’re Here, They’re Queer, and They’re Going to Save the World


Hulu only murders in the building poster Hulu only murders in the building poster

Why You Should Be Watching Only Murders in the Building