Connect with us
Stoker movie review
Image: Fox Searchlight Pictures

Film

Looking back at Stoker and the reoccurring case of the disappointing third act

Chan-wook Park’s Stoker is a Gothic fairytale, a family drama, and a beautifully twisted, pitch-black coming-of-age story, all at once. This slow-burning psychological thriller isn’t afraid to enter uncomfortable places, often edging close to taboo territory. Park wants his audience to twitch in their seats, and the master director can accomplish this with the greatest of ease. Along with first-time screenwriter Wentworth Miller, Park weaves a coming-of-age tale through a tangled, murderous family plot loaded with sexual subtext and upper-class entitlement. People disappear, a landscape of family secrets is revealed, and Park teases the audience into anticipating the worst. With Alfred Hitchcock’s classic Shadow of a Doubt serving as a template, Stoker’s first two acts are, without a doubt, impeccably crafted. The problem comes in the third act. Its script doesn’t quite carry the dramatic heft of his earlier work, much less Hitchcock’s 1943 masterpiece.

What starts as a film that is stylishly spooky and effectively eerie, with an air of quiet eroticism, quickly shifts into a TV movie of the week, with a third act plagued with explanation, exposition, and exploitation. The movie works best when it retains its mystery by withholding information and allowing that information to be disclosed in tiny increments. A great deal of information is withheld at the start, and not just from the audience but from our protagonist, India, as well. But the revelations in the final scenes are a tad disappointing. In Stoker’s third act, all the buildup is overshadowed by some leaps in plausibility and worse, character logic.

c_scalefl_progressiveq_80w_800
Image: Fox Searchlight Pictures

The majority of the pic’s running time feels somewhat like a surreal fantasy, and one could assume the events that unfold may be figments of India’s own feverish imagination. As India sets out to explore forbidden grounds and dark secrets, she becomes lost in her sexual awakening. This isn’t the case for the final few scenes, which take the viewers away from India’s home, her eyes, and her mind and presents us with flashbacks that outright dismiss the possibility that Stoker can be interpreted as a fervid dream. Learning Uncle Charlie’s backstory only turns the movie upside down and over on its head. So in assessing Stoker, one must ask if all the talent on display is enough to dismiss a plot that feels forced, mannered, and, ultimately, empty. While individual scenes removed are poetically horrifying and beautifully rendered, as a whole, Stoker is silly.

When the credits roll, if questions are left unanswered, it can be a good thing, depending on what an audience is asking. But when those questions challenge the character’s motivations, reactions, and decisions, it can leave viewers frustrated. The end result is a film less interested in narrative suspense than in carefully orchestrated cross-cutting and meticulous framing. It is said that Park did not have final cut and was forced to edit out 20 minutes of the film. One can’t help but wonder what kind of film Park might have made if he’d had full creative control. One can’t help wondering why Hollywood would even hire such a talent if they did not have faith in him. Park has made it clear in interviews that there were disagreements between him and the studio (Fox Searchlight), and so instead, we have this movie, a film which had the potential to be a masterpiece if not torn between Park’s idiosyncratic vision and Hollywood’s unwillingness to taking risks.

Ricky D

stoker-1024
Image: Fox Searchlight Pictures
Written By

Some people take my heart, others take my shoes, and some take me home. I write, I blog, I podcast, I edit, and I design websites. Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Goomba Stomp and Tilt Magazine. Host of the Sordid Cinema Podcast and NXpress Nintendo Podcast. Former Editor-In-Chief of Sound On Sight, and host of several podcasts including the Game of Thrones and Walking Dead podcasts, as well as Sound On Sight. There is nothing I like more than basketball, travelling, and animals. You can find me online writing about anime, TV, movies, games and so much more.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook

Trending

Russell Simmons’s Alleged Rape Victim Accuses Him Of Fleeing To Bali

Celebrity

Azealia Banks Expresses Pity Over Kim Kardashian’s Intimate Photoshoot With A Tesla Robot

Celebrity

Grammy Nominations 2025: Beyonce Leads With 11 Nods as Taylor Swift, Chappell Roan, Sabrina Carpenter and Charli XCX Are Among Top Nominees

News

‘Paddington in Peru’ Review: A Diverting Threequel Sets a National Treasure on a Treasure Hunt

Film

Lamar Jackson Net Worth: How He Became NFLs Richest QB

Celebrity

Lamar Odom Takes Heat For Buying A Sex Doll That Resembles Ex-Wife Khloe Kardashian Lamar Odom Takes Heat For Buying A Sex Doll That Resembles Ex-Wife Khloe Kardashian

Lamar Odom Takes Heat For Buying A Sex Doll That Resembles Ex-Wife Khloe Kardashian

Celebrity

Why Pharrell Got Fired from McDonald’s 3 Times

Celebrity

Bridget Moynahan Net Worth: From Modeling to $25 Million

Celebrity

Yellowstone recap: A new wrinkle in John’s murder investigation complicates matters for the Dutton clan

Film

Newlyweds Justin Long and Kate Bosworth to Co-Star in Survival Thriller ‘Coyote’

Film

Amy Schumer Net Worth: From Comedy to Hollywood Success

Celebrity

‘Paradise at Mother’s Feet’ Review: A Trek to Mecca Starts Heading in the Wrong Direction

Film

Zack Snyder to Direct LAPD Action Thriller at Netflix

Film

King Combs Posts Heartbreaking Tribute To His Mother Kim Porter On Her Death's Anniversary King Combs Posts Heartbreaking Tribute To His Mother Kim Porter On Her Death's Anniversary

King Combs Posts Heartbreaking Tribute To His Mother Kim Porter On Her Death’s Anniversary

Celebrity

Waka Flocka Flame Hints At Kanye West Album Dropping In December

Celebrity

Shaboozey, Benson Boone, Doechii, Daniel Nigro and Amy Allen to Be Honored at Variety’s Hitmakers Event; Jack Antonoff Named Producer of the Decade Shaboozey, Benson Boone, Doechii, Daniel Nigro and Amy Allen to Be Honored at Variety’s Hitmakers Event; Jack Antonoff Named Producer of the Decade

Shaboozey, Benson Boone, Doechii, Daniel Nigro and Amy Allen to Be Honored at Variety’s Hitmakers Event; Jack Antonoff Named Producer of the Decade

Culture

Connect